Differences in major joint play testing grades

-
The pioneers of joint play testing

The two principal pioneers of joint play testing in manual therapy are Geoffrey Maitland of Australia, and Freddy Kaltenborn of Norway. Both individuals developed techniques for the extremities and spine, and both developed different scales for describing the force and movement used during testing and treatment.

Essential Differences between the Australian and the Nordic Approach

During the development of his approach, Maitland was strongly influenced by the neurophysiologic principles relating to pain. Kaltenborn on the other hand was influenced by the joint based mechanical approaches advocated by Cyriax, Mennel, and Stodard.

1. Basic differences in approaches:
Maitland’s approach (non-diagnostic approach): Maitland’s approach uses angular motions in the extremities when looking at joint play. Logically, angular movements of the long bones may be used to identify abnormal resistance due to muscle guarding, muscle tone, or articular restriction. However, because of its gross nature, it is difficult to judge whether articular or neuromuscular impairments are causing a particular movement restriction.

Kalternborn’s approach: Drawing from simple mechanical principles Kaltenborn reasoned that there are two types of movement available in a joint: rolling and gliding. Understanding that, excessive loading (sheer and compression) leads to articular cartilage degeneration Kaltenborn chose to emphasize straight-lined, translational (gliding) movements during joint examination, mobilization, and manipulation. His techniques are performed using very small amplitudes of movement with forces applied close to the joint line.

2. The scales developed: The scales developed by Maitland and Kaltenborn are equally dissimilar. Kaltenborn’s scale looks at resistance within the range while Maitland’s scale looks at the amplitude of oscillations within the range. Some manual therapy systems integrate these two scales which causes confusion for the novice manual therapist.

3. Kaltenborn & Maitland’s Initial Treatment Directions: Kaltenborn and Maitland target their initial treatments differently. Maitland advocated treating patients with pain by directing oscillations towards the direction of movement causing pain (but not into pain). Kaltenborn on the other hand emphasized treating to improve function using directions that cause the least amount of pain.

(excerpt from my manual therapy class:8)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Entrapment of medial calcaneal nerve (MCN)

-
Image
Peripheral nerve entrapment is a rare, but important, cause of foot and ankle pain that often is underdiagnosed and mistreated. A peripheral nerve may become entrapped anywhere along its course, but certain anatomic locations are characteristic (2). The medial calcaneal nerve (MCN) The Tibial nerve is called the planter nerve in the sole. The tibial nerve passes to the sole of the foot takes a turn on the medial side of the calcaneum is called MCN. The medial calcaneal nerve arises from tibial nerve of the inner side of the ankle, perforates the laciniate ligament, travels downwards passing below the bony projection on the inner side of the ankle, and supplies the skin over the medial aspect of the heel. Hence it is the most important nerve for heel sensations. MCN have 2 branches. The anterior branch dominate the cutaneous sensation of the anterior part of the medial calcaneal and heel weight loading field, while the posterior branch dominate the sensation of the posterior an...
Read more

Differential diagnosis of Anatomic (Radial) snuffbox pain: It is not always DeQuervain’s tenosynovitis.

-
Image
Tendon, Bone & Ligament causes: 1. DeQuervain’s tenosynovitis: Swelling of tendon of APL (Abductor pollicis longus) & extensor pollicis brevis at lateral wrist near anatomic snuff box.  The primary complaint is radial sided wrist pain that radiates up the forearm with grasping or extension of the thumb. The pain has been described as a “constant aching, burning, pulling sensation." Pain is often aggravated by repetitive lifting, gripping, or twisting motions of the hand. Swelling in the anatomical snuff box, tenderness at the radial styloid process, decreased CMC abduction ROM of the 1st digit, palpable thickening of the extensor sheaths of the 1st dorsal compartment and crepitus of the tendons moving from the extensor sheath may be found upon examination. Other possible findings include weakness and paresthesia in the hand. Finkelstein’s diagnostic test will present positive provoking the patient’s symptoms. If left untreated, the inflammation and progressive narro...
Read more

Chronic fatigue syndrome

-
Introduction: Severe fatigue is a common complaint among patients. Often, the fatigue is transient or can be attributed to a definable organic illness. Some patients present with persistent and disabling fatigue, but show no abnormalities on physical examination or screening laboratory tests. In these cases, the diagnosis of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) should be considered. According to Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC, USA) Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) currently is defined as: (1) fatigue of at least 6 months' duration, seriously interfering with the patient's life; and (2) without evidence of various organic or psychiatric illnesses that can produce chronic fatigue. The World Health Organization classifies myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome (ME/cfs) as a nervous system disease. Together with other diseases under the G93 heading, ME/cfs shares a triad of abnormalities involving elevated oxidative and nitrosative stress (O&NS), activat...
Read more